Logan
represents the latest instalment in Fox's long running X-Men
franchise. Using Marvel characters, while not actually being part of
the MCU, this franchise can be best described as patchy. Most are OK,
some have aged poorly, several are dire, but with the notable
exception of Deadpool, they've yet to completely nail it. One thing
they did however get right first time was Logan A.K.A Wolverine A.K.A
James Howlett, A.K.A Mutant McStabbyhands, the antisocial berserker
of an ensemble cast. Logan the character is probably only just below
Batman in terms of recognisability, but most of the films about him
are meh at best. Logan the film, what we are talking about
today, exists mainly because actor Hugh Jackman wishes to retire from
the role after sixteen odd years. And fortunately, it isn't meh. In
fact, its probably gonna be on a lot of people's shortlists for best
Superhero film, 2017.
The main reason is its conceit. This
film has an unusually bleak premise with subtle themes of dystopia,
which honestly put me in mind of one of those
non-canon/elseworlds/what-if stories. Its NOT directly based on the
Old Man Logan comic series, with the only real similarity being Logan
happening to be an old man in a crappy world. Mutants are dying out,
not at the hands of killer robots, but due to the mysterious lack of
mutant births. The X-Men are gone, with seemingly the only survivors
being Wolverine, and Professor X A.K.A Charles. Neither is ageing
well, with Charles having a brain disease and Wolverine working as
chauffeur to support both of them, now needing glasses to read. Into
this comes Laura A.K.A X-23 a new mutant of about 10, and a team of
cyborg mercenaries chasing her. With extreme reluctance, and the
promise of money, Wolverine drives her to safety. Unfortunately for
him, and those he must protect, Wolverine is dying, his mutant
healing factor all but spent. He does not survive the trip, and at
one point discusses suicide.
As I say, bleak. Wolverine, the embodiment of male bloodlust and endurance, hobbles around covered in scars, drinking his regrets, and finding even his claws are failing him. But more than that is the sense of regret. The X-Men failed. Mutants look to be going out not with a bang, but with a whimper. Professor X is not only in mad grampa territory, but did something Wolverine won't discuss. And Wolverine himself has killed more men than cancer, and has nothing to show for it than guilt and a broken body held together with painkillers and booze. The world they live in is not overtly hostile, but one of faded glory, run-down tourist traps, and corporations. With the film having scenes in Mexico, its easy to draw comparisons with Trump's America, but that's not the point. The point is legacy, as evidenced by the X-Men comics Laura adores, but Wolverine decries as false. And blood. Lots of blood, and how it marks a person. Logan invokes the classic Western Shane, both featuring scenes and dialogue from it to hammer home this point. And the result is a powerful drama that owes more to the Western genre than superheroes, with some unapologetically brutal fight scenes. And make no mistake, this isn't the “GRIMDARK” or “edgy neon” favoured by the DC stable so far. This bleakness is earned, not an affectation.
As I say, bleak. Wolverine, the embodiment of male bloodlust and endurance, hobbles around covered in scars, drinking his regrets, and finding even his claws are failing him. But more than that is the sense of regret. The X-Men failed. Mutants look to be going out not with a bang, but with a whimper. Professor X is not only in mad grampa territory, but did something Wolverine won't discuss. And Wolverine himself has killed more men than cancer, and has nothing to show for it than guilt and a broken body held together with painkillers and booze. The world they live in is not overtly hostile, but one of faded glory, run-down tourist traps, and corporations. With the film having scenes in Mexico, its easy to draw comparisons with Trump's America, but that's not the point. The point is legacy, as evidenced by the X-Men comics Laura adores, but Wolverine decries as false. And blood. Lots of blood, and how it marks a person. Logan invokes the classic Western Shane, both featuring scenes and dialogue from it to hammer home this point. And the result is a powerful drama that owes more to the Western genre than superheroes, with some unapologetically brutal fight scenes. And make no mistake, this isn't the “GRIMDARK” or “edgy neon” favoured by the DC stable so far. This bleakness is earned, not an affectation.
That said, Logan's flaws
manifest in the third act, where some time-honoured superhero
cliches, and Fox's general incompetence, come home to roost. One of
the monsters chasing Laura which Wolverine must defeat, proves to be
an evil clone of himself in black, something so chronically
unimaginative as to ruin my first viewing. While not without symbolic
meaning, its symbolism wielded like a cosh, and feels much dumber
than everything before it. A better way? Make it someone more
intimately involved with Wolverine, such as his male offspring Daken,
or Sabretooth. You add lots more drama that way, this just feels like
a cost saving. On a similar note, the fate of mutant kind and the
machinations of Xander Rice feel as trite as any previous X-Men film
that tried similar. Perhaps these plot elements should have been
left unexplained. Then there's the matter of basic continuity, which
is broken in ways both big and small. This is best evidenced by the
casting of Stephen Merchant as Caliban, but this character was also
played by Tómas Lemarquis last year in Apocalypse,
and while not to diminish either actor, the performances are also
incompatible with each-other. It seems nobody at Fox realised the character was in both films, which is face-to-palm stupid. The film
does not match up with Days of Future Past either, with neither
timeline fitting this narrative.Given that this movie is sold on
Jackman's retirement following an unusually long tenure, that lack of
continuity is shameful. While these errors are easily ignored in the
experience of watching, this contracts sharply with the care taken
with characterisation and direction. Paradoxically, its best viewed
as a separate entity from the previous films, while being reliant on
the broad strokes for most of its impact.
Its a good film. Fox might finally be
getting their act together.
Image Copyright Fox, used under fair use provisions.
No comments:
Post a Comment